Mackinac Island Peanut Butter Fudge
Formulated using only the finest and freshest ingredients, our premium ice cream is crafted in small batches to deliver a well-balanced creamy taste you won’t soon forget.

Classic Mackinac Island Peanut Butter Fudge Flavor

Creamy peanut butter ice cream swirled with thick fudge and peanut butter truffles.

MACKINAC ISLAND PEANUT BUTTER FUDGE ICE CREAM

Since 1940, Guernsey Farms Dairy has brought families together over wholesome, small-batch dairy crafted with care. Our milk is sourced directly from a single local dairy farm, ensuring every scoop meets our high standards for freshness and taste.

Our Mackinac Island Peanut Butter Fudge Ice Cream blends smooth peanut butter ice cream with rich chocolate fudge ribbons and peanut butter truffles, delivering a genuine taste of Michigan nostalgia.

Taste the Guernsey Difference

As a third-generation family business in Northville, MI, we take pride in time-tested recipes and a welcoming community atmosphere. Beyond finding our cartons at local grocery stores, guests visit our family restaurant and scoop shop for memorable meals and desserts. When you choose Guernsey Farms Dairy, you enjoy traditional quality crafted with pride.

Planning a weekend family outing or stocking up on your favorite treats? Stop by our Northville scoop shop or explore our ice cream flavors to find your next family favorite today!

FAQs

What ingredients make this flavor unique compared to traditional fudge flavors?

This recipe blends rich peanut butter ice cream with dense chocolate fudge ribbons and decadent peanut butter truffles for a multi-layered flavor profile inspired by historic Michigan candy shops.

Where can customers purchase Guernsey Farms Dairy ice cream tubs?

You can buy our 48oz containers at grocery retailers across Southeast Michigan or pick up both 48oz and 3-gallon sizes directly from our Northville restaurant and scoop shop.

Is the Northville restaurant open year-round for dining and ice cream visits?

Yes, our family restaurant and scoop shop operate year-round, serving classic comfort food alongside our full line of handcrafted dairy treats.

How does single-farm sourcing improve ice cream taste and texture?

Receiving fresh milk directly from one trusted local farm allows complete quality control, resulting in higher cream consistency, pure flavor, and superior smoothness in every batch.

Does the Northville location accommodate large groups or family gatherings?

Our destination restaurant warmly welcomes families and large groups looking to enjoy dessert outings and community dining experiences together.

Availability
48oz,  3 Gallon
Gluten Free Icon
Allergens
Milk, Peanuts, Soy